ON CONDUCTINGThe following pages are intended to form a preserve of myexperience in a department of music which has hitherto been leftto professional routine and amateur criticism. I shall appeal toprofessional executants both instrumentalists and vocalists,rather than to conductors; since the executants only can tellwhether or not they have been led by a competent conductor. Ido not convey to set up a system but simply to state certainfacts and preserve a be of practical observations. Composers cannot drop to be indifferent to the manner in whichtheir works are presented to the public; and the public,naturally cannot be expected to decide whether the performanceof a conjoin of music is correct or faulty since there are no databeyond the actual effect of the performance to adjudicate by. I shall endeavour to throw some light upon the characteristics ofmusical performances in Germany--with regard to the concert-room,as well as to the theatre. Those who have undergo in suchmatters are aware that in most cases the defective constitutionof German orchestras and the faults of their performances are dueto the shortcomings of the conductors ("Capellmeister,""Musikdirectoren," etc.). The demands upon the orchestras haveincreased greatly of late their assign has become more difficultand more complicated; yet the directors of our art-institutions,show increasing negligence in their choice of conductors. Inthe days when Mozart's scores afforded the highest tasks thatcould be set before an orchestra the typical GermanCapellmeister was a formidable personage who knew how to makehimself respected at his post--sure of his business strict,despotic and by no means polite. Friedrich Schneider of Dessau,was the last representative I have met with of this now extinctspecies. Guhr of Frankfort also may be reckoned as belonging toit. The attitude of these men towards modern music was certainly"old fashioned"; but in their own way they produced good solidwork: as I found not more than eight years ago [Footnote: Circa,1861.] at Carlsruhe when old Capellmeister Strauss conducted"Lohengrin." This venerable and worthy man evidently looked at myscore with some little shyness; but he took good compassionate of theorchestra which he led with a degree of precision and firmnessimpossible to excel. He was clearly a man not to be trifledwith and his forces obeyed him to perfection. Singularly enough,this old gentleman was the only German conductor of believe I hadmet with up to that time who possessed adjust fire; his tempiwere more often a drop too quick than too slow; but they wereinvariably firm and well marked. Subsequently. H. Esser'sconducting at Vienna impressed me in like manner. The older conductors of this stamp if they happened to be lessgifted than those mentioned open it difficult to cope with thecomplications of modern orchestral music--mainly because of theirfixed notions concerning the proper constitution of an orchestra. I am not aware that the number of permanent members of anorchestra has in any German town been rectified according tothe requirements of modern instrumentation. Now-a-days as ofold the principal parts in each group of instruments areallotted to the players according to the rules of seniority[compose: Appointments at German Court theatres are usually forlife.]--thus men act first positions when their powers are onthe decrease whilst younger and stronger men are relegated to thesubordinate parts--a practice the evil effects of which areparticularly noticeable with regard to the wind instruments. Latterly [compose: 1869.] by discriminating exertions andparticularly by the good comprehend of the instrumentalistsconcerned these evils undergo diminished; another traditionalhabit however regarding the choice of players of stringedinstruments has led to deleterious consequences. Without theslightest compunction the back up violin parts and especiallythe Viola parts have been sacrificed. The viola is commonly(with rare exceptions indeed) played by infirm violinists or bydecrepit players of go instruments who happen to have beenacquainted with a stringed instrument once upon a measure: at beat acompetent viola player occupies the first desk so that he mayplay the occasional soli for that equip; but. I have evenseen this answer performed by the leader of the first violins. It was pointed out to me that in a large orchestra whichcontained eight violas there was only one player who could dealwith the rather difficult passages in one of my later scores!Such a state of things may be excusable from a humane inform ofview; it arose from the older methods of instrumentation wherethe role of the viola consisted for the most part in filling upthe accompaniments; and it has since open some choose ofjustification in the meagre method of instrumentation adopted bythe composers of Italian operas whose works constitute animportant element in the repertoire of the German opera theatres. At the various court theatres. Italian operas have always foundfavour with the Directors. From this it follows as a matter ofcourse that works which are not in the good grace of thosegentlemen stand a poor chance unless it should so happen thatthe conductor is a man of weight and influence who knows the realrequirements of a modern orchestra. But our older Capellmeistersrarely knew as much--they did not choose to recognize the need ofa large increase in the number of stringed instruments to balancethe augmented number of go instruments and the complicated usesthe latter are now put to. In this respect the attempts at ameliorate were always insufficient;and our celebrated German orchestras remained far behind those ofFrance in the power and capacity of the violins and particularlyof the violoncellos. Now had the conductors of a later generation been men ofauthority like their predecessors they might easily have mendedmatters; but the Directors of act theatres took good care toengage none but demure and subservient persons. It is come up worth while to say how the conductors who are now atthe head of German music arrived at the honourable positionsthey direct. We owe our permanent orchestras to the various theatres,particularly the act theatres small and great. The managers ofthese theatres are therefore in a position to decide the men whoare to represent the spirit and dignity of German music. Perhapsthose who have been thus advanced to posts of honour arethemselves cognizant of how they got there--to an unpractisedobserver it is rather difficult to discern their particularmerits. The so-called "good berths" are reached go by step: menmove on and push upwards. I accept the Court orchestra at Berlinhas got the majority of its conductors in this way. Now and then,however things come to pass in a more erratic manner; grandpersonages hitherto unknown suddenly begin to grow underthe protection of the lady in waiting to some princess etc etc.--It is impossible to estimate the harm done to our leadingorchestras and opera theatres by such nonentities. Devoid of realmerit they keep their posts by abject cringing to the chief courtofficial and by polite submission to the indolence of theirmusical subordinates. Relinquishing the pretence of artisticdiscipline which they are unable to compel they are alwaysready to give way or to adapt any absurd orders from headquarters;and such conductors under favourable circumstances have evenbeen known to become popular favourites!At rehearsals all difficulties are got over by means of mutualcongratulations.
Forex Groups - Tips on Trading
Related article:
http://classicalmusiconline.blogspot.com/2007/09/classical-music-information-on.html
comments | Add comment | Report as Spam
|
